Luke Skywalker Needs a Wife


Star Wars: The Last Jedi was beautifully filmed and full of surprises. I enjoyed the film, but it had some issues. There’s a lot I could say about it, but for now I want to talk about one character: Luke Skywalker. When we met Luke in the original trilogy, he was full of hope, willing to rush off to save his friends, and ready to confront evil on the slim chance that he could redeem his father. Luke didn’t give up easily. Who is this guy in The Last Jedi? Scared, in hiding, selfish. Sure, he arguably gets his act together by the end of the movie, but really, I’m disappointed in you, Luke.

While discussing this with my spouse, it became clear what went wrong with this version of Luke. He needs a wife! Specifically, he needs Mara Jade! Would Mara have allowed Luke to wallow in self-pity? No, she would have kicked him in the head and said “Get up farm boy; you are better than this!” Would Mara Jade have let Luke’s nephew to go dark without confronting him? No! She would have ambushed him in her StealthX starfighter and fought him in the tunnels of Kavan! OK, that’s a very specific reference and it didn’t end well, but you get the idea! Would Luke have been so self-centered if he had a wife? Of course not! Would Mara have allowed Luke to seemingly waste 30 years after the battle of Endor? No, she would have pushed him, challenged him, and made very sure he was able to continue the Jedi Order!

Life is so much better with an awesome wife. Poor Luke in The Last Jedi; if only he had a wife.


Reading Star Wars


Since the release of The Force Awakens, I’ve had some people ask me about the Star Wars books: where should a new reader begin? Well, it depends. Which continuity are you interested in? If you aren’t familiar with Star Wars continuity, check out my earlier post, Star Wars Continuity Explained. If you want to read Disney’s new canon, then the number of books available to you is relatively small (at least as of May 2017).

On the other hand, if you want to read the Legends continuity, things are a bit more complicated. There are over 150 novels in Legends, and that isn’t including comic books, young adult fiction, etc. You could read through the books chronologically, starting with Dawn of the Jedi: Into the Void and ending with Crucible. I wouldn’t recommend it. That is a lot of books, and you are likely to get bogged down at some point.

A second option is to read the books in the order they were published. I would also advise against this, for similar reasons.

Instead, I’d recommend you start with the book that fundamentally shaped the Legends continuity, Timothy Zahn’s 1991 novel, Heir to the Empire. Don’t stop there – it is a trilogy! Once you have read Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising, and The Last Command, then you have many options to choose from. My recommendations and some brief commentary are below…

Disney Canon
This is for those who want to stick with the new canon. Read these in any order:

  • Thrawn – My favorite in the new canon so far, but then again I was already a fan of the character.
  • Lost Stars – This one is actually a YA novel, but is very good. It gives differing perspectives on the Galactic Civil War from two compelling characters.
  • Ahsoka – Another YA book, but if you are a fan of Clone Wars or Rebels, you’ll want to check this out.
  • Bloodline – A nice look into Leia’s life before The Force Awakens.
  • Tarkin – An interesting look into Tarkin’s background
  • Catalyst – A prequel to Rogue One… Read it, and watch Rogue One again!
  • Aftermath Trilogy – I’m honestly not a fan of this author’s writing, and the first book in particular I found disappointing. That said, the second and third books were intriguing and provide some hints at how things progress towards The Force Awakens.

Legends: New Republic
A reading list for those who want to stay in the timeframe and continuity of Heir to the Empire. This list is exactly what I read my daughters when they expressed an interest in Star Wars novels.

  1. Thrawn Trilogy (Heir to the Empire, Dark Force Rising, The Last Command) – start here; these are fantastic.
  2. Dark Empire Trilogy – Contains what is probably the most fan-contested plot point in Legends, but worth a read. This is the only comic book series I’m including in this post. There’s actually a ton of great Star Wars comics, but I’ll save that for another post. I’m including this one because it was an early influencer of the Legends continuity.
  3. The Jedi Academy Trilogy – Fans like to criticize the writing and stories of these books, but I enjoyed them as a youngster. They are fun and contain a lot of details that are referenced and built upon later.
  4. The Courtship of Princess Leia – Reading this is actually jumping back in (Star Wars) time, but this book is worth reading. It has some important universe-building concepts, and it is just fun, although the fundamental premise is a bit wacky.
  5. Hand of Thrawn Duology (Specter of the Past, Vision of the Future) – Honestly, these are my least favorite of Timothy Zahn’s Star Wars books, but they were still enjoyable. They continue the mythology of Thrawn, and establish some important aspects of Legends continuity.

Legends: The New Jedi Order
If you’ve completed the New Republic books, this is the next chronological series. Summary: a extra-galactic species that exists outside of the Force invades the Star Wars galaxy. It is a contentious story among fans: some fans hate the premise, but I personally love it, although the series was too long…19 books! As a bonus, read Rogue Planet, set between Episodes 1 and 2 as a prequel era tie-in. 20 books is a big commitment!

Legends: Legacy of the Force
If you make it through The New Jedi Order, this is the next chronological series. Summary: the galaxy is torn apart as… well, really anything more is a spoiler. I’m a fan of the core storyline here, although some of side stories I could do without – the Mandalorian story in particular didn’t hold my interest. There’s a lot of interpersonal strife here, which I think is good for character development, but it is a rough ride for the Skywalkers and Solos.

Legends: Fate of the Jedi
After Legacy of the Force, this is the next chronological series. Summary: a lost civilization of Sith come into contact with the larger galaxy, and an ancient powerful Force being emerges. This series starts off slowly, and has some odd aspects, but overall it was worth a read. I really enjoyed seeing an ancient Sith culture thrust into the Star Wars galaxy, and one character in particular was a great addition: Vestara Khai. Bonus: read Lost Tribe of the Sith (a short story collection) for some “historical” context.

Legends: Crucible
If you read all of Fate of the Jedi, wrap things up with Crucible. It is the last novel, Star Wars chronology-wise, in Legends.

Legends: X-Wing series
These are fan favorites, written by two authors. I personally prefer the books by Michael Stackpole, and I’ll admit not finishing this series after Aaron Allston took over the writing. These are set in the New Republic era, but they can be read independently of everything else.

Legends: Darth Bane Trilogy
This trilogy describes the beginnings of the Sith’s rule of two. Great characters, set very early in the timeline. Kind of dark, as you’d expect.

Legends: Various
Here are some recommendations that mostly can be read independently of everything else.

  • Darth Plagueis – Excellent book, includes Palpatine’s backstory
  • Cloak of Deception – Nice lead in to The Phantom Menace. Palpatine at his manipulative best (or worst?)
  • Survivor’s Quest – Mara and Luke investigate Outbound Flight. This is set several years after Vision of the Future, but before The New Jedi Order. Best when read after the New Republic books.
  • Outbound Flight – Great backstory on Outbound Flight, Jorus C’Baoth, and Thrawn. Ties in nicely with the new canon’s Thrawn. Best when read after the New Republic books and Survivor’s Quest.
  • Revenge of the Sith trilogy (Labyrinth of Evil, Revenge of the Sith, Dark Lord) – A book before and a book after Revenge of the Sith makes for a more complete and interesting story of the Empire’s and Vader’s beginnings.
  • Kenobi – One of my favorites. An awesome look at Kenobi on Tatooine.
  • Death Star – An inside look at the Death Star, before Catalyst and Rogue One gave us a new story.
  • Allegiance and Choices of One – A Zahn duology set between A New Hope and Empire. Cool to see Mara and Thrawn in a different time period.
  • Shadows of the Empire – Fills in the details of what happens between Empire and Jedi. This book was a big deal when it was released, with a comic book, toy line, soundtrack, and so forth.

I hope you find this post useful if you are a new Star Wars reader!

A Review of Star Wars: Thrawn

Last year when it was announced that Grand Admiral Thrawn would be appearing in season 3 of Star Wars Rebels, I was excited. When that announcement was followed with news of a new Thrawn novel by Thrawn’s creator, Timothy Zahn, I realized I was looking forward to the novel much more than the television season. As it turns out, my anticipation was properly placed. Seeing Thrawn in Rebels was fun, but somewhat underwhelming. Star Wars: Thrawn, on the other hand, was great!

Timothy Zahn has always been one of my favorite Star Wars authors, and he didn’t disappoint here. The story was fun and engaging, and it brought a new depth to several characters. This book is set in Disney’s new continuity, but it is written in such a way that it can mostly fit into the previous Legends continuity. In particular the events of Outbound Flight are not contradicted, and the first chapter of Thrawn is very similar to Mist Encounter. That said, the book is firmly in the new canon, and leads directly into the events of Rebels Season 3. References to evils lurking in the Unknown Regions applies equally well to Legends (the Yuuzhan Vong) and whatever is being alluded to in the new canon (see Aftermath: Empire’s End).

A few other highlights for me: the reader gets into Thrawn’s head to understand how he thinks, the Chiss Ascendancy is now canon, H’sishi is back in canon, Governor Pryce is given an interesting backstory, and Sy Bisti returns as a language.  Overall, a fun read that stands on its own but really shines if the reader is familiar with Legends or with Star Wars Rebels.

Why Star Wars fans are so excited about Grand Admiral Thrawn’s return

Thrawn_novelStar Wars Celebration Europe ended today, and for many Star Wars fans, the most exciting news by far was the return of Grand Admiral Thrawn. For the casual fan, this reasons for this excitement might not be obvious.

Thrawn (full name: Mitth’raw’nuruodo) is one of the most beloved characters from Star Wars Legends. He’s a cool, calculating, non-human genius who cares more about order and stability in the galaxy than personal power. He’s not your typical Star Wars villain. Not only that, his debut was in the novel that effectively kicked off the Expanded Universe, Heir to the Empire, one of the more popular books in Star Wars Legends.

Thrawn is going to be in Rebels Season 3 and in a new book by Timothy Zahn. This is awesome for the obvious reasons that we get both television and novel content, but there’s more to it than that. First, we are finally seeing Disney’s canon take on a significant character from Legends. It means something to fans to know that there are real opportunities to see characters who we love show up again. Secondly, Timothy Zahn is writing in the new canon! That alone is great, and the fact that he is crafting a Thrawn story makes it that much better. The fact that Zahn was involved with the planning of Thrawn’s appearance in Rebels shows that the Lucasfilm Story Group is serious about getting this right.Rebels_Season3_poster

For me personally, it was absolutely fantastic to sit next to my two oldest daughters and see the excitement on their faces when Thrawn was revealed in the Rebels Season 3 trailer! We’ve been reading the Legends books together for a couple of years now, and we’ve also been watching Rebels, so the two coming together is perfect.


Bits from The Force Awakens Novelization

The_Force_Awakens_novelizationI finally finished reading the novelization of The Force Awakens (a couple of other books distracted me), and there were several interesting things near the end.

Han and Leia are married
When Han sees Leia: “Husband and wife stood regarding each other…” The film doesn’t specify if Han and Leia were still married by the time of The Force Awakens. Actually just going by the movie it isn’t clear if they were ever married. Glad to see that point cleared up. Although I’m still frustrated by their relationship overall; they did so much better in Legends… oh well.

Han hasn’t seen Kylo Ren’s face in 10 years
“For the first time Han saw the face of his son as a grown man…” Kylo Ren is around 29-30 years old during the events of The Force Awakens, so we can assume that Han hasn’t seen Kylo’s face for around 10 years. That’s longer than I expected.

Kylo is weakened
After Kylo murders his father, he falls to his knees and “found himself weakened”. I find it interesting that the act that Kylo hoped would make him stronger actually had the opposite effect.

Kylo knows who Rey is
After Rey calls the lightsaber to herself, Ren murmurs “It is you.” Kylo Ren believes that Rey is someone in particular, not just a surprisingly strong Force user.


C-3PO’s Red Arm

Marvel’s C-3PO #1 (aka C-3PO: The Phantom Limb) finally was released this month, after a long wait! The comic book was originally supposed to be part of the “Journey to Star Wars: The Force Awakens” publishing program leading up to the release of The Force Awakens, but that didn’t happen. I ordered my copy in October, and had nearly forgotten about it!

It was a good story, providing a satisfying explanation for why C-3PO would actually choose to keep a non-matching limb. I found the story a little slow going at first, but the themes of droid sentience and free will were intriguing. Honestly, my favorite part was the inclusion of the “spice spiders,” bringing an element of Legends into the Disney canon.


Star Wars Continuity Explained

Do the various stories in all the Star Wars books, comics, games, and cartoons fit together as a single cohesive story? No, they don’t. There are two major Star Wars continuities, what I’m going to refer to as “Legends” and “Disney.”

Before Disney acquired Lucasfilm, there was a very large body of Star Wars content (books, comic books, games, cartoons) collectively known as the Expanded Universe. It told the story of what happened outside of the movies. Disney made the choice to brand this material as “Legends” and start from scratch with their storyline.

The Star Wars Disney continuity is comprised of the first six films (Episodes I – VI), the Clone Wars cartoon, and everything published since Disney took over. That includes The Force Awakens, all novels since A New Dawn, the Rebels cartoon, and the comics published by Marvel starting in 2015. Often this continuity is referred to as the “new canon” or just “canon” material.

The Star Wars Legends continuity basically includes everything else, although there’s some nuance to consider. The original six movies still “happened” in Legends, despite not being part of Legends. Generally speaking, Legends tells a fairly consistent story, particularly considering the large volume of material that needs to fit together. However, there’s a few big exceptions to this:

  1. Keeping a unified continuity didn’t seem to be a priority before Heir to the Empire was published in 1991, so don’t expect earlier works to fit in cleanly. The early Marvel comics are good example of this.
  2. Another problem area is The Clone Wars cartoon series. Despite being released before Disney’s acquisition, it stomped all over established continuity at the time. I prefer to just think of this cartoon as part of the Disney continuity only. Unfortunately that doesn’t quite work out, because some Legends material references content from the cartoon.
  3. Some Legends stories are “what if” stories, and not intended to be part of the Legends timeline. These are known as “infinities” stories.

For a more in-depth view of Legends and canon, see the “Canon” page on Wookieepedia.

Since Disney’s Legends decision, I’ve seen lot of the comments basically saying that that the old stories “aren’t true”, “didn’t happen”, or “don’t matter” anymore. I see things differently: there are now two Star Wars timelines, that happen to intersect at some points. Like any good mythology there’s not just one story. The old stories didn’t become less entertaining or less valuable. Sure, many Star Wars fans will only ever know Disney’s version of events, but anyone who wants to dig a little deeper can find a fascinating alternate Star Wars in Legends.

Originally posted by me, January 10, 2016, on